Powder & Bulk Solids is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

When Things Go Wrong: How to Address a Solids Flow Problem

Article-When Things Go Wrong: How to Address a Solids Flow Problem

Silo collapse
Silo collapse

As a consultant to the bulk solids handling industry for so many years, I have been involved in numerous approaches to solids handling problems. The process usually starts problem. This typically results in the submission of a with a telephone conversation concerning a particular proposal for material testing and conceptual design recommendations.
    Some of the problems and their results that are frequently brought to my attention are as follows:
    "I can’t get my material out because it bridges and ratholes in my bin.” Material to your process stops flowing as a result of a flow obstruction such as a bridge or rathole. Your operator opens the gate or turns on the feeder expecting material to flow freely from the bin. All of sudden, material stops flowing and he is required to use a flow aid device such as a sledgehammer to initiate flow. Maybe you have designed your silo to store 100 tons of product and because of a stable rathole forming, only 10 tons of your product is actually live.
    “My process is upset due to erratic material flow.” Flow within your system is erratic such that processes (driers, kilns, packaging lines, etc.) have to turn off and on frequently to accommodate flow stoppages. Not only is the handling equipment affected by this erratic operation, but the upstream and downstream equipment is also affected by it.
    “Sometimes my fine powder floods from the bin all over the floor.” This is nasty problem in that fine powders can flow uncontrolled like a liquid and end up all over the floor. Perhaps you are filling packages and your product floods the process, overfilling bags and containers, or at the very least, creating a tremendous dust cloud, and more importantly, a safety issue.
    “The quality of my final product is affected by the fine and coarse particles of my material segregating.” Segregation can affect the quality of the end product you produce or make. It can also result in dissatisfied customers who are expecting material that is within a certain particle size range or density and receive off-spec material. The coarse and fine particles have separated during handling. (see photo)
    “Help! My silo has collapsed!” (see photo) Asymmetric flow patterns caused by ratholes, preferential flow channels, etc., can cause silos to dent, buckle, and even collapse. Collapsing ratholes and bridges can also lead to silo failure problems.
    Here are some things to remember when discussing flow problems:

Material Properties

What material(s) are you handling?
What is their moisture content and how is it measured? What is their particle size?
Are they exposed to temperature variations such as dried product entering a bin at 150°F and cooling to room temperature?
How long does the material remain at rest in the silo? This is critical to determine the effect storage at rest on the cohesive strength of the product.
What is the bulk density?
What discharge rate do you require from the silo or bin?

Silo Geometry

What is the current bin diameter or capacity requirement for a new bin? What is the shape of the existing hopper?
What is the size of the opening? How is it filled?
What is the silo or bin fabricated from lined or coated with? What type of feeder is used to control discharge rate?
What equipment is upstream and downstream of the bin or silo?

    This list is just the beginning of the information one needs to collect to evaluate a flow problem or design a new bin or silo. Other information, such as drawings or sketches of the existing equipment, is always necessary. Segregation problems typically require a site visit in order to fully understand the cause of the segregation problem and provide reliable solutions to those problems.

    Joseph Marinelli is a consulting engineer and president of Solids Handling Technologies. He has been providing testing and consulting services since 1972.  As a former consultant with Jenike & Johanson Inc., he has years of experience testing powders and designing bins and feeders for reliable flow. He lectures frequently on the topic of powder handling, and has published several papers including an article in a chemical encyclopedia and two articles in a food powder book. For more of Joe's Powder Perspectives, visit our Powder Persepctives section.

Joseph Marinelli
Solids Handling Technologies
1631 Caille Court
Fort Mill, SC 29708
[email protected]

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.