AC/DC Level Sensors Make the TransitionAC/DC Level Sensors Make the Transition

October 16, 2014

7 Min Read
AC/DC Level Sensors Make the Transition
click here to view full image

One hundred fifteen VAC has been the dominant power supply for powering a wide range of industrial devices, such as control units, sensors, final control elements, etc. Particularly during most of the 20th century, sensors required significant power to function and simply “plugging it in the wall” was an easily implemented solution and the power 115VAC (110/115/120) supplied was virtually limitless.
    However, as the last century came to a close, it became clearer than ever that 24VDC power systems were replacing the use of 115VAC in North American industrial areas for a variety of process measurement and control instrumentation equipment. Forward-thinking sensor manufacturers had the increasing impetus, ability, and opportunity to assist users in the transition and make it simple. Some did, some didn’t – especially when it came to the bread and butter level sensor control technology for powder and bulk solids, the economical class of rotary paddle bin level indicator.

Background
Level sensor technology has evolved significantly over the years. One of the oldest technologies used for powder and bulk solids level detection is the rotary paddle bin level indicator. This technology dates back at least as far as the mid-1930s when The Fuller Co. was given a patent on what is arguably the first rotary paddle bin level indicator design in the U.A. Since then, this technology has evolved and many other sensing techniques have come along. Today, the most commonly used technologies for bulk solids level detection include rotary paddle, RF admittance, capacitance and vibrating element (tuning fork or rod probe).
    The rotary paddle unit is arguably the “king of the hill” of point level sensors for powder and bulk solid materials. Use includes high level detection for fill control, low level detection for material reorder points and production run-out protection, plugged chute detection, as well as intermediate level detection for rough material inventory indication. Whatever the use, the heart of the rotary paddle point level sensor has always been the drive motor assembly. For the basic economical rotary paddle unit the drive motor has typically operated directly on the chosen power supply of the system within the unit is installed.
    Most power sources within North America have been 115VAC and this remains as a common power source today. However, increasing in popularity and use is 24VDC power. This means that rotary paddle units have had to incorporate a DC drive motor. The most common type of DC drive motor used in rotary paddle units have very limited life, approximately 5000 hours. For high level applications – where the motor is operating most of the time - this can equate to as little as seven months.
       Other types of point level sensors, those solid state devices like RF admittance, capacitance, and vibrating element probes have been able to incorporate DC voltage power supplies without any reduction in life because their circuitry have always operated at lower DC voltages.

Why the Shift from AC to 24VDC
It is clearly the inherent aspect of “safety” that tends to drive the use of 24VDC power systems in process control functions and systems. In the past it has been the protection of equipment and the prevention of fires that have been the impetus for safety standards. However, an increasing shift in recent decades has occurred towards focusing on the safety of people, in addition to that of the protection of equipment and preventing fires. In recent years it has become common thinking that whenever voltages can be reduced to levels considered safe, that it should be implemented. Whenever energy levels can be reduced to eliminate arc flashes, this implementation is strongly considered one that will greatly enhance safety. An “arc flash” is defined by the Workplace Safety Awareness Council as when a flashover of electric current travels through the air from one conductor to another, or to ground, and the results are often serious personnel injury and even death.
    Reduction in voltage is a good thing in regard to safety, and has increasingly been done in process and electrical control systems as a way of improving personnel safety and improving ease of working with equipment. OSHA Standard 29CFR 1910.269 is clear when it says that operating voltages >50 volts are considered “high risk” for personnel to be exposed. Therefore these high-voltage systems like 115VAC must be disconnected when personnel are working on any components that are fed by this high voltage. This OSHA standard clearly indicates that “live parts to which an employee may be exposed shall be de-energized before the employee works on or near them.” This makes working on high-voltage equipment and system more time consuming and difficult. Not so with 24VDC power systems. The OSHA standard further states “live parts that operate at or less than 50 volts to ground need not be de-energized if there will not be increased exposure to electrical burns or explosion due to electrical arcs. The NFPA standard 70E also indicates that dangerous voltages are anything over 30 volts. Sensors that can operate from 24 volts therefore enhances the ability of the power system used in the process measurement and control system to be inherently safe and easier to work with in the installation, repair, and operation of the equipment connected with 24VDC. The use of the 24VDC power system can virtually eliminate potential safety hazards.

The Universal Power Supply
Level measurement and detection sensors must help users manage the transition between high-voltage AC power supplies and low-voltage - typically DC - power supplies. How do sensor manufacturers do this? The universal power supply is the answer. True universal power supplies are needed within the level detection type of device, e.g. point level sensor, level control, bin level indicator, etc. Continuous level measurement sensors, such as RF admittance level transmitters, radar level transmitter, etc., have long been available as two-wire loop-powered devices operating on 18-30VDC loop power. Higher priced point level sensors cost around $400 and up. This pricing allows room for the inclusion of a universal AC/DC supply that allows the transition between AC to DC supplies with a single unit. But the low cost or economical version of the rotary paddle bin level indicator has typically not had the price structure to embed a universal power supply - at least not until recently. Recent advancements in surface mount electronic technology and global design techniques have resulted in the availability of rotary paddle bin level indicators with a universal AC/DC power supply for around $200. The universal power supply accepts 20-250V power and can be either AC or DC voltage. This technology automatically determines the incoming voltage and type and converts it to the even lower voltages used by the level indicator to perform its functions reliability and long term.
    The device pictured provides this type of universal power supply and uses a low-voltage AC drive motor. This is a significant achievement as it allows this rotary paddle bin level indicator to operate on DC voltage power, while eliminating the short life DC drive motor of older designs. While not the first device to eliminate the DC motors in DC-powered units, the uniqueness is the implementation of a 20-250VAC/VDC universal power supply that allows easy and affordable transition from high-voltage AC power supplies to the safer low-voltage AC and DC supplies with a single device at an affordable price.

Conclusion
Low-voltage DC power systems are safer and becoming increasingly popular among users desiring to implement safer and OSHA compliant electrical power systems that simplify the installation, repair and operation of their electrical system for process measurement and control. Bin level indicators being installed within these low-voltage DC systems are called to operate in this power environment. While this has been possible for many years, only recently have economical rotary paddle devices been equipped with power supplies that assist the user by providing a “universal power supply” that allows the use of a wide range of voltages, either AC or DC with a single device. The trend towards 24VDC power supplies for safety, efficiency, and speed of process control will continue. Users should increasingly look for and require sensor devices that can operate within the installed voltage systems today, and tomorrow, with a single affordable device.
    Joe Lewis is responsible for directing and leading Aplus Finetek Sensor Inc. USA operations. He has more than 35 years in the process measurement and control industry, a BSEE from Roger Williams University, and an MBA from Bryant University, both in Rhode Island. He is a senior member of the ISA and has spent the last 20+ years in various business, marketing, and production roles for powder and bulk solids instrumentation companies. He can be reached at 815-632-3132 or [email protected]. For more information on Aplus Finetek Sensor Inc., visit www.aplusfine.com.

Sign up for the Powder & Bulk Solids Weekly newsletter.

You May Also Like